Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joost Emanuel's avatar

The journalist says it plainly: journalists are not allowed into trilogues, and decisions with enormous consequences can rest on a few exhausted negotiators.  That is not a fringe observation; it is an admission that the formal democratic process narrows into a small, opaque bargaining room.

This episode shows us the machine.

Europe’s carbon market is not mainly decided by voters, scientists, or people already living with floods, heat, and rising bills. It is decided in closed negotiations between the Commission, national governments, members of the European Parliament, and industry.

The stated goal is cutting emissions. The practical question, again and again, becomes: **how do we protect industry, jobs, and energy prices first?**

So free pollution permits may be extended. New carbon rules may be delayed. Firms may be called “security.” Climate victims may disappear from the room.

POSIWID asks one simple thing: **do not judge the machine by its promises—judge it by what it repeatedly does.**

Who gets the permits?

Who pays the bills?

Who gets protection?

Who is left outside the room?

Listen for the machine.

Here are a few background links to deepen and widen the field here:

https://escapekey.substack.com/p/settled-science?r=8ei5r5&utm_medium=ios

https://escapekey.substack.com/p/the-new-economics-foundation?r=8ei5r5&utm_medium=ios

https://escapekey.substack.com/p/stranded-assets?r=8ei5r5&utm_medium=ios

Ready for more?